Reviews
State Farm® Agent Natalie Mathews
Our customers are the center of our universe and we're grateful for them.
If you're willing to share your experience about your interaction with our agency, it'll be a great help for other people looking to make smart and confident decisions about their insurance and financial services.
Leave us a review
Get a quote today
What our customers say about us...
Brian Wasko
October 23, 2026
"Great customer service! Ruby wen the team always go above and beyond to help! Thank you!"
"Thank you for the thoughtful review - we really appreciate you taking the time to share your experience with our Bonita Springs insurance team. "
Nick Holman
October 23, 2026
"Terrific customer service!"
"Nick, thank you for your 5-star review - we truly appreciate your feedback and are so glad you had a positive experience with our team here in Bonita Springs. If you need anything at all, don’t hesitate to reach out! - Your State Farm Agent Natalie Mathews and Team "
Chris Antonopoulos
October 14, 2026
"Ruby was amazing to work with.She is very professional and to the point .Thank you Ruby you rock."
"Thanks so much for the great review! We’re thrilled to hear you had such a positive experience with our insurance team here in Bonita Springs. "
Diane Joseph
October 10, 2026
"Ruby took the time to find the answers to my questions"
"Thanks so much for the fantastic rating, Diane! We’re so glad you had a great experience with our team. Don’t hesitate to reach out anytime—we’re here for you! "
Reyven Bedard
September 24, 2026
"I’ve been with this particular branch for several years now, and could not be happier with the prompt service and personal touch that I get from all of the staff members, especially Erika."
"Reyven, thank you so much for the 5-star rating! If you ever have questions or need assistance, our team is always here to help. "
Charlotte Jackson
September 22, 2026
"I recently called State Farm with questions regarding my insurance premiums. I was hoping to speak with Natalie Mathews, my agent, but Ruby Marski answered the phone. Ruby was incredibly polite, courteous, and knowledgeable about all three of my policies. She was very helpful and took the time to answer my questions. I really appreciated her professionalism and excellent customer service. Thank you, Ruby!"
"Thanks so much for the great review! We’re thrilled to hear you had such a positive experience with our insurance team here in Bonita Springs. "
Roger Beardmore
September 22, 2026
"Erika was my point of contact for a collision claim. She was UNBELIEVABLY GOOD. Very prompt, professional, and helpful. She took care a multiple problems for me and went the extra mile to ensure client satisfaction."
"Thank you so much for the 5 stars, Roger! We really appreciate your support. If you ever need anything, feel free to reach out anytime. "
Robert Anthony
September 14, 2026
"I have always received outstanding service from Natalie's office.
Ruby and the other agents and staff have been very friendly and responsive to questions regarding coverage and billing."
"Hi Robert, thank you so much for your kind review! We really appreciate you taking the time to share your experience with us here on State Farm Agent Natalie Mathews’s team. Please reach out to us if any questions come up! - Natalie Mathews’s Insurance Team "
Mike Carlson
September 1, 2026
"Wonderful agency. Always kind, courteous, and prompt in resolution. They always place the customer first. I am grateful that I found this agency and am happy to suggest them to others."
"Thank you for your encouraging words it means so much to us. We're here if you need anything"
Erika N
August 19, 2026
"I love my local office! Staff is always nice and welcoming. They answer all my questions and concerns. 10/10"
Debbie Hagney
August 19, 2026
"Great fast service! One quick call and my bill is paid."
"Debbie, thank you for the fantastic rating! We’re committed to providing honest, reliable service, so we’re so glad that came through in your experience. "
Swfl Tile
July 18, 2026
"Kyle is super amazing and is a great fit for Natalie Matthews State Farm really knows his stuff. It’s a pleasure to have him on board. Thank you for such a good job. I have been using State Farm for the past 10 years we were with a different agent before Natalie Matthews. Natalie Matthews and her husband Bonita and Estero are by far the best State Farm agents in the area. They have hired a new girl Nadia and she is absolutely one of the best Representative agents I have ever seen. She is attentive to detail and knows exactly what’s going on with your file when you call. She is a great fit for Natalie Mathews State Farm and I think that she should be training other individuals to act and know how to deal with certain situations. I was dealing with a payment issue when I called in and she was able to calm me down and get me back on track in a matter of second. Natalie Matthews runs an amazing establishment and it is a real pleasure to know that I’m covered with such an amazing firm thank you. I’m a local CEO of Gulf Coast builders"
Linda Underwood
May 4, 2026
"The nice & friendly phonecall was surprisingly VERY quick & efficient. I love that the person who answers the phone takes immediate care of my needs."
Annamarie Healy
April 9, 2026
"Excellent customer service. Highly recommend this agency! Their insurance staff is the very best! Erika is always so helpful. Very patient and knowledgeable. Highly recommend State Farm, in particular, this agency."
Mary Ann Woods
December 26, 2025
"Great job on ensuring my BMW and I’ll be leaving it here in St. Louis when I come home March 1 so thank you very much for all your insurance"
Ted Hoxie
December 8, 2025
"I have both my house and car insurance at this company.
Fast, efficient service by Kyle and team!"
Greg Koepfer
November 7, 2025
"I recently had a claim that I filed. Unfortunately it was denied. The reason was that I did not have collision insurance on the car. The new car was financed and was required. State Farm knew the car was financed but did not include the coverage. Somebody at State Farm made a mistake. It was her Fiduciary responsibility to make sure that I had the right coverage. After several attempts to get this resolved her office just said they couldn't do anything. Any attempt to contact her myself or the claims department have been ignored."
Samuel Levinson
October 17, 2025
"The agents that I dealt with were knowledgeable and very responsive. They took care of my needs and were a pleasure to work with."
Ellen Moran
September 23, 2025
"Great service and very pleasant people. Really like this group.
Efficient and professional while being warm."
Gayle Wood
September 12, 2025
"We appreciate the friendliness and professionalism of Natalie Matthews and her entire staff at the State Farm agency in Bonita Springs, Florida. It is reassuring to have our insurance needs met by a large insurance company like State Farm and talking to everyone in this particular agency is always a pleasure."
Doug Hurlbutt
September 9, 2025
"It was such a pleasure to work with Natalie! I called looking to insure my vehicle, Natalie made the whole process super smooth!!! I 100% recommend her for all your insurance needs!!!"
"Thank you so much for your kind review! I am so glad we could make the insurance process smooth for you. It was a truly a pleasure working with you and we are here for anything you need. "
Andrew Pierre
July 9, 2025
"I had all but very good experience with all the staff communication skills are excellent."
Leslie Kureth
July 1, 2025
"Everytime I call they are very professional & answers every question I might have. The prices are good. Very Happy with State Farm!!!😊"
JOSEPH LAROCCA
June 30, 2025
"Great help"
Paula Hartsfield
June 30, 2025
"When I met with Natalie and then talked with her on the phone over a year later, she explained things in a way that I understood. She was complimentary of my work to be knowledgeable of insurance coverage. Natalie seems to remember me from that meeting in her office which I appreciate."
"Thanks so much for the kind words! It was great chatting with you again, and I’m really glad I could explain things in a way that made sense. I definitely remembered our meeting—it means a lot to me to build real connections with the people I work with. Appreciate you taking the time to leave a review!"